No Child Should Be Bought or Sold. It’s Time to Draw the Line on Commercial Surrogacy.
Nov 20, 2026 by FACT
Surrogacy in Tennessee is not strictly classified as legal or illegal – it exists in a murky gray area. There is no licensing requirement, no standard for the agencies that broker these arrangements, and no limit on who may “order” a child. This lack of regulation in an industry rife with ethical dilemmas is putting countless children and women in harm's way. It’s time for Tennessee to take a clear stand.
The Tennessee Supreme Court considered this topic 12 years ago. Ruling on a disputed surrogacy contract in 2014, Chief Justice Gary Wade wrote that “our statutes offer limited guidance as to how courts should handle surrogacy disputes.” Justice William Koch agreed in a concurring opinion: “The broader public policy questions should be left to the General Assembly.”
Twelve years later, the General Assembly still hasn’t formalized a stance on surrogacy. Without clear guardrails, surrogacy can be (and often is) exploited to take advantage of vulnerable women for financial gain, as well as to victimize and commodify children.
The United States is one of the few medically advanced nations that still allows commercial surrogacy. France, Germany, Italy, and Spain prohibit surrogacy outright. Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia allow it only when no money changes hands. In March 2023, 100 experts from 75 nations, most of them lawyers, doctors, and psychologists, signed the Casablanca Declaration calling on governments to abolish the practice altogether.
Last fall, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, Reem Alsalem, stated at UN headquarters: “The consequences of surrogacy are so grave and harmful and result in large scale violations of the human rights of surrogate mothers and their children that surrogacy as a practice as an industry must be abolished.”
Child advocates like Katy Faust, founder of Them Before Us, have been sounding the alarm for years:
Surrogacy splices what should be one woman—mother—into three purchasable and optional women: the genetic mother, or egg “donor,” who grants the child their biological identity; the birth mother, with whom the baby develops their first, critical bond; and the social mother, who provides daily female care to maximize the child’s development and satisfy the child’s longing for maternal love.
For children, none of these three mothers are optional. Studies have shown that if children never know their genetic mother, they often experience identity struggles. If they lose their birth mother, some believe that children experience a “primal wound” that makes bonding, trust, and attachment more challenging. And if they are deprived of a social mother, their development is impacted.
No matter what form it takes—traditional or gestational, altruistic or commercial, commissioned by gay or straight adults—surrogacy takes something away from the child. It’s not a loss that results from a fallen world, where parents who cannot or should not care for their child seek to redeem that loss through adoption. It is the infliction of an intentional loss simply because an adult wants it that way. And that violates several biblical mandates.
We encourage you to read more of Katy Faust’s analysis of surrogacy from a biblical perspective here. She also pointed out a critical element of this conversation from a legal perspective: “There are no adoption-like requirements for intended parents to undergo screenings, vetting, or background checks. Surrogacy also relies on direct payments to genetic/birth parents, which is arguably a form of child trafficking.”
When a couple adopts in Tennessee, the state requires a home study and a background check before a child is placed with an unrelated family. Tennessee law sets no such requirement when a child is commissioned through a surrogacy contract.
Children are a gift from God, and no child should be bought and sold. Tennessee law should say so.
Ending the unethical practice of commercial surrogacy in the state of Tennessee will be one of FACT’s top priorities in the 2027 Legislative Session. We want to draft and propose legislation that answers the question our Supreme Court left to lawmakers in 2014.
We estimate that drafting, advocating for, and passing this measure will require at least $25,000 in funding.
Will you prayerfully consider supporting this effort before lawmakers convene in Nashville this January? A contribution of $25, $50, $100, or more goes a long way in helping us protect vulnerable women and children in Tennessee.
Thank you for standing with us. You are helping create a state and nation where God is honored, life is cherished, and religious liberty flourishes. We couldn’t fulfill this important mission without you!
The Tennessee Supreme Court considered this topic 12 years ago. Ruling on a disputed surrogacy contract in 2014, Chief Justice Gary Wade wrote that “our statutes offer limited guidance as to how courts should handle surrogacy disputes.” Justice William Koch agreed in a concurring opinion: “The broader public policy questions should be left to the General Assembly.”
Twelve years later, the General Assembly still hasn’t formalized a stance on surrogacy. Without clear guardrails, surrogacy can be (and often is) exploited to take advantage of vulnerable women for financial gain, as well as to victimize and commodify children.
The United States is one of the few medically advanced nations that still allows commercial surrogacy. France, Germany, Italy, and Spain prohibit surrogacy outright. Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia allow it only when no money changes hands. In March 2023, 100 experts from 75 nations, most of them lawyers, doctors, and psychologists, signed the Casablanca Declaration calling on governments to abolish the practice altogether.
Last fall, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, Reem Alsalem, stated at UN headquarters: “The consequences of surrogacy are so grave and harmful and result in large scale violations of the human rights of surrogate mothers and their children that surrogacy as a practice as an industry must be abolished.”
Child advocates like Katy Faust, founder of Them Before Us, have been sounding the alarm for years:
Surrogacy splices what should be one woman—mother—into three purchasable and optional women: the genetic mother, or egg “donor,” who grants the child their biological identity; the birth mother, with whom the baby develops their first, critical bond; and the social mother, who provides daily female care to maximize the child’s development and satisfy the child’s longing for maternal love.
For children, none of these three mothers are optional. Studies have shown that if children never know their genetic mother, they often experience identity struggles. If they lose their birth mother, some believe that children experience a “primal wound” that makes bonding, trust, and attachment more challenging. And if they are deprived of a social mother, their development is impacted.
No matter what form it takes—traditional or gestational, altruistic or commercial, commissioned by gay or straight adults—surrogacy takes something away from the child. It’s not a loss that results from a fallen world, where parents who cannot or should not care for their child seek to redeem that loss through adoption. It is the infliction of an intentional loss simply because an adult wants it that way. And that violates several biblical mandates.
We encourage you to read more of Katy Faust’s analysis of surrogacy from a biblical perspective here. She also pointed out a critical element of this conversation from a legal perspective: “There are no adoption-like requirements for intended parents to undergo screenings, vetting, or background checks. Surrogacy also relies on direct payments to genetic/birth parents, which is arguably a form of child trafficking.”
When a couple adopts in Tennessee, the state requires a home study and a background check before a child is placed with an unrelated family. Tennessee law sets no such requirement when a child is commissioned through a surrogacy contract.
Children are a gift from God, and no child should be bought and sold. Tennessee law should say so.
Ending the unethical practice of commercial surrogacy in the state of Tennessee will be one of FACT’s top priorities in the 2027 Legislative Session. We want to draft and propose legislation that answers the question our Supreme Court left to lawmakers in 2014.
We estimate that drafting, advocating for, and passing this measure will require at least $25,000 in funding.
Will you prayerfully consider supporting this effort before lawmakers convene in Nashville this January? A contribution of $25, $50, $100, or more goes a long way in helping us protect vulnerable women and children in Tennessee.
Thank you for standing with us. You are helping create a state and nation where God is honored, life is cherished, and religious liberty flourishes. We couldn’t fulfill this important mission without you!